Aisle Seat Holiday Gift Guide From HARRY POTTER to INGLOURIOUS
BASTERDS, The
Latest Blu-Ray and DVD Titles Reviewed
Peter Hyams has enjoyed
a long and diverse career behind the lens,
having directed fine genre films like “Capricorn One” and “2010,” as
well as the enjoyable monster flick “The Relic.” Unfortunately Hyams’
first new movie in several years, a remake of Fritz Lang’s 1956 RKO
thriller BEYOND
A REASONABLE DOUBT (*½, 105 mins., 2009, PG-13), ranks
as his worst.
Severely miscast and
indifferently directed, “Beyond a Reasonable
Doubt” stars Jesse Metcalfe -- best known from TV’s “Desperate
Housewives” -- as a young investigative TV reporter who decides to
expose a corrupt Shreveport, Louisiana D.A. (a particularly tired
Michael Douglas) by falsely implicating himself in a murder. Metcalfe’s
plans go all wrong once his back-up disc housing evidence of his
innocence go up in smoke, leaving his new girlfriend (Amber Tamblyn),
also one of Douglas’ young attorneys, to try and get Metcalfe off the
hook before he heads to the electric chair. Metcalfe comes off like
he’s subbing for Mario Lopez on “Access
Hollywood” with a glib, empty lead performance, and he has zero
chemistry with Tamblyn, who’s been good in other roles but seems stiff
and overly mannered here, as if she’s straining to be “serious.” With
neither lead working effectively, you become all too aware of the
predictability and shallowness of Hyams’ script, which telegraphs plot
points so blatantly that the film offers no surprises at all. Add in an
embarrassing “chase” sequence with Tamblyn trying to get away from one
of Douglas’ thugs, and an ending that’s downright laughable, and you
have a movie that simply sits there and dies on-screen through its 105
minutes. Indeed, it’s downright depressing to see both Douglas and
Hyams (who collaborated over 25 years ago on “The Star Chamber”)
reduced to bad direct-to-video fodder like “Beyond a Reasonable Doubt.”
Anchor Bay’s Blu-Ray
edition of the picture sports a terrific 1080p
transfer with plain 5.1 Dolby Digital sound. This is one of the few
Hyams movies not shot in a 2.35 aspect ratio, with the 1.85 transfer
still seeming well composed with deep contrasts, as well as
illustrating Hyams’
typical penchant for low-level lighting. David Shire’s score does what
it can to add a touch of class to the movie, but the film ultimately is
so pedestrian that it’s a losing battle.
Extras include
commentary with Hyams and Metcalfe, the trailer, a
digital copy of the picture, and a behind-the-scenes featurette. Those
extras (sans the digital copy) are also on the DVD edition, which
boasts a 16:9 (1.85) transfer also with 5.1 Dolby Digital sound.
There’s no question this
one is just plain bad, beyond any reasonable
doubt!
New From Universal
PUBLIC ENEMIES
Blu-Ray and DVD (**½, 140 mins., 2009, R; Universal).
WHAT IT IS: Michael Mann’s chronicle of the relationship between John
Dilinger (Johnny Depp), his love Billie Frechette (Marion Cotillard)
and the FBI agent pursuing his criminal path across the U.S. (Christian
Bale) is a disappointing thriller that fails to reach the heights of
“Heat.” Depp is just fine as Dillinger and Cotillard shines in her
sequences, while Mann, as always, indulges in a few exciting
set-pieces, backed by potent sound design and a fine (if occasionally
anachronistic) Elliot Goldenthal score. Yet the film manages to be a
tad cold and almost bland, failing, surprisingly enough, to capture the
era with little period detail. “Public Enemies” never really takes off,
yet it’s still well-crafted and polished enough to keep you watching
despite its shortcomings. DVD BREAKDOWN: Universal’s two-disc Blu-Ray
and DVD editions of “Public Enemies” are hurt by Mann’s newfound
preference for shooting on digital video, which occasionally exhibits
some jarring video artifacts at certain points on both transfers. The
movie still has stylish lighting from Mann and cinematographer Dante
Spinotti, but the overall look of the movie is a major disappointment
coming from the director. Extras include commentary with Mann and
numerous Making Of featurettes, along with a digital copy disc in the
BD package. AISLE SEAT MERRY BOTTOM LINE: Between the cast and director
much was expected from “Public Enemies,” but the final result did not
live up to its potential. For whatever reason, the material just never
catches fire here.
INGLOURIOUS
BASTERDS Blu-Ray (***, 153 mins., 2009, R; Universal). WHAT
IT IS: Quentin Tarantino’s latest excursion into the offbeat is one of
my
favorite films of his to date -- an uneven but cinematically vibrant
collage of
snappy dialogue, studied tributes to other pictures and most of all the
WWII film genre itself, here reinvented as a Jewish revenge fantasy
with
Brad Pitt leading a squad of Jewish soldiers into Nazi occupied France
for revenge. Even if the Basterds themselves are -- disappointingly --
only peripheral characters, the central, interlocking story is
stylishly designed and leisurely told, with
Tarantino taking advantage of the wide cinematic frame and employing a
number of techniques to get his story across. Among the memorable
performances are Christoph Waltz as a most vile Nazi commander and
Melanie Laurent as the only surviving member of a Jewish family he
wipes out in the film’s opening set-piece; in addition to a few
voice-overs
from Samuel L. Jackson there are also “Guest Star” turns from Mike
Myers and Rod Taylor as Winston Churchill along for good measure! Add
in a
typically eclectic Tarantino soundtrack, offering music as varied as
cues from “The Alamo,” Morricone westerns, "Cat People," "Kelly's
Heroes" and even Charles Bernstein’s
“The Entity,” and you have another Tarantino cinematic stew that’s pure
revisionist history, but also quite entertaining...even though the film
sags as it moves along, coming off more like a slow burn than a real
thriller. There should have been a bit more action and less talk in one
of his later "Acts," particularly considering that the Q-man delivers
the goods in a memorable, albeit brief, climax. TECH SPECS: Universal’s
Blu-Ray disc is one of
the year’s most satisfying HD presentations, marked by a perfect 1080p
transfer and DTS Master Audio soundtrack. Of course it helps that
Tarantino knows the language of cinema, particularly from a visual
angle; compare this to the dreary, video-like appearance of Michael
Mann’s “Public Enemies” and it’s a night and day
difference.
Extras
include a full array of deleted and extended scenes plus numerous
featurettes, roundtable interviews, and a digital copy for portable
media players. AISLE SEAT MERRY BOTTOM LINE: Though “inspired” by Enzo
Castellari’s ‘70s exploitation favorite, Tarantino offers up another of
his stylistic endeavors in “Inglourious Basterds,” but the results fuse
together more successfully here than in most of his prior works. It's a
shame there wasn't a bit more "pop" to the film's second half, though,
since the "Basterds" really never get an opportunity to strut their
stuff.
9 Blu-Ray and
DVD (**½, 80 mins., 2009, PG-13; Universal). WHAT IT IS:
Shane Acker’s award-winning short subject became a generally
well-received feature last fall, directed by Acker and produced by Tim
Burton and “Wanted”’s Tibur Bekmambetov. In Pamela Pettler’s adaptation
of Acker’s original story, a group of sock puppets are charged with
carrying on the legacy of humanity after robots and machines launch an
apocalypse on earth. Nightmarish visuals, well-executed animation and
an oddball sci-fi story separate “9" from typically goofy Dreamworks
CGI fare, though the slender plot has a hard time holding up through
its 80 minute duration, and the ending isn’t especially satisfying. DVD
BREAKDOWN: Universal’s DVD edition of “9" boasts an expectedly crisp
16:9 (1.85) transfer with an involving 5.1 Dolby Digital soundtrack,
offering a fine Danny Elfman-Deborah Lurie score. Acker’s original
short is one of the special features, along with commentary from Acker
and other behind-the-scenes talent and making of featurettes. The
Blu-Ray edition, meanwhile, is even more impressive with its 1080p
transfer and DTS Master Audio soundtrack. AISLE SEAT MERRY BOTTOM LINE:
“9" will be available after Christmas and comes recommended for
fantasy/animation enthusiasts in spite of its flaws.
A PERFECT
GETAWAY Blu-Ray and DVD (**½, 98 mins/108 mins., 2009,
R/Unrated; Universal). WHAT IT IS: Twisty and watchable thriller
from David Twohy follows couple Steve Zahn and Milla Jovovich on an
Hawaiian honeymoon when word gets out that a killer is on the loose.
Could the suspects be adventure-seeking duo Timothy Olyphant and Kiele
Sanchez, or perhaps Marley Shelton and Chris Hemsworth? It’s fun in the
sun with Zahn going increasingly off the rails as he suspects anyone
and everyone of being the killer, and Twohy throwing in a few
convoluted plot twists and self-aware dialogue (Zahn is supposed to be
playing a screenwriter) for good measure. It doesn’t add up to a whole
lot, but for those of us in cold weather inclines, “A Perfect Getaway”
at least makes for a diverting enough way to kill off 100 minutes. TECH
SPECS: Universal’s Blu-Ray edition of “A Perfect Getaway” is a winner.
Offering both the theatrical cut and a longer Unrated version (which
extends the film by 10 minutes), the Blu-Ray’s 1080p transfer and DTS
Master Audio soundtrack are both superb, boasting vivid colors and
contrasts. Alas, extras are slim, outside of an alternate ending and BD
Live connectivity. That same ending is also on the standard DVD, which
boasts a 16:9 (2.35) transfer and 5.1 Dolby Digital audio. AISLE SEAT
BOTTOM LINE: It’s not exactly a ringing endorsement but “A Perfect
Getaway” isn’t a terrible choice for viewing at this time of the year,
though I confess its sunny Hawaiian locales go down mighty nice in HD
when it’s 25 degrees out!
Also New This Week
Having grown up on the
movies of Mel Brooks and Gene Wilder, I’m
excited to report that Fox has brought a series of Mel’s finest to
Blu-Ray in a lavishly produced high-definition box-set.
The superlative,
nine-film anthology THE MEL BROOKS
COLLECTION basically reprieves the studio’s prior Brooks DVD
compilation in new high-def transfers, housing the comedian’s entire
output with Fox (“Young Frankenstein,” “Silent Movie,” “High Anxiety,”
“History of the World Part I,” “To Be Or Not To Be” and “Robin Hood:
Men In Tights”), with the addition of “The Twelve Chairs” and “Blazing
Saddles,” the latter on loan from Warner Bros., plus “Spaceballs” from
MGM (sadly “The Producers” is still MIA).
Six of the nine films in
Fox’s collection have never been released
before on Blu-Ray, making this release absolutely essential for any
Brooks fan. Here’s a breakdown:
Brooks’ early THE TWELVE CHAIRS
(**½, 93 mins., G, 1970) is a surprisingly restrained
adaptation of a 1920s Russian folk tale, with Brooks starring alongside
Ron Moody, Dom DeLuise and Frank Langella. The movie has its admirers
though I’ve never been a huge fan of the picture, which is presented in
a crisp and satisfying AVC encoded presentation with both DTS Master
and mono sound, and no extras save a gallery of
trailers.
“The Twelve Chairs” is
on-hand along with BLAZING SADDLES
(***½, 93 mins.,
1974, R) and YOUNG
FRANKENSTEIN (****, 102 mins., 1974, PG), both in the same
Blu-Ray editions Warner and Fox previously released (for a full rundown
on “Young Frankenstein,” read my original review here).
These are complimented
in the box-set by all of Mel’s later work for
Fox -- five films that, like “The Twelve Chairs,” debut on Blu-Ray
herein.
Those later efforts are
highlighted by the delightful 1976
SILENT MOVIE (***, 87 mins., 1976, PG)
as well as the intermittently uproarious Hitchcock spoof HIGH ANXIETY (***, 1977, 94 mins., PG),
complete with one of Brooks’ more memorable collaborations with
composer John Morris (isn’t it well beyond the proper time for a CD
retrospective of Brooks’ and Morris’ film music? Goodness knows with
the veritable weekly parade of limited edition soundtracks we’re
seeing, there should be ample room for more of Morris’ soundtracks than
we’ve gotten so far, LaLaLand’s superb “Blazing Saddles” and
“Spaceballs” excepted).
Both movies hit Blu-Ray
in matching AVC encoded 1080p transfers with
both DTS Master stereo sound on each platter; each print looks a bit
aged at times but the heightened detail and clarity of both transfers
will be quite satisfying for Brooks buffs, while a decided lack of
digital noise reduction means grain is still happily evident. All-new
extras on “Silent Movie” include a retrospective look at the picture’s
production with comments from Brooks and John Morris among others, plus
a Hollywood history trivia track and a full compliment of trailers.
“High Anxiety,” meanwhile, offers an isolated score track in full DTS
Master Audio 5.1, along with another 25-minute look back upon the
production, a silly “Am I Very Very Nervous Test” that pops up
on-screen, and more trailers.
Brooks’ HISTORY OF THE WORLD: PART I
(**, 92 mins., 1981, R) was one of the director’s few flicks I
couldn’t watch as a kid (due to its R rating), but it turns out I
wasn’t missing much, as this rambling and often unfunny farce has one
inspired, five-minute musical number -- memorably sending up the
Spanish Inquisition (presumably a warm-up for Brooks’ later “Producers”
musical) -- but precious little else to recommend it. Fox’s Blu-Ray
platter once again sports a superb DTS Master Audio soundtrack and
crisp AVC encoded transfer, plus another DTS Master isolated score
track, two interview segments with Brooks (one on the movie, the other
on his “Inquisition” song), a trivia track and trailers.
Thankfully, Brooks
returned to form in 1983's TO BE OR
NOT TO BE (***, 107 mins., PG),
a collaboration with wife Anne Bancroft that fueled an engaging remake
of the Ernest Lubitsch early ‘40s classic. Once again offering some
new, exclusive extras, Fox’s Blu-Ray includes a look back on the
production with comments from Brooks, Tim Matheson, Dick Van Patten,
and others, alongside a brief vintage promo featurette, a trivia track,
and another robust DTS Master Audio isolated score track. Visually the
AVC-encoded transfer looks much healthier than “High Anxiety” and
“Silent Movie,” though it’s too bad that Brooks’ memorable “To Be Or
Not to Be” music video wasn’t dusted off for this release.
As the ‘80s wore on,
Brooks’ directing output dried up, with the
mediocre SPACEBALLS (**½, 96
mins., 1987, PG; see my original review of the Blu-Ray here) followed by the
even-worse “Life Stinks” -- a major stinker indeed for MGM, the latter
grossing a paltry $4 million total in its domestic run.
Thankfully, before
hitting almost rock bottom again with the dismal
“Dracula: Dead and Loving It,” Brooks reverted to at least respectable
form with the genial 1993 parody ROBIN
HOOD: MEN IN TIGHTS (**½, 104 mins., PG-13, 1993).
A mix of Brooks veterans
(Dick Van Patten, Dom DeLuise) works with a
game assortment of younger comedians (Richard Lewis, Tracy Ullmann, and
even Dave Chappelle) for this predictable, slightly overlong, but
nevertheless amusing assortment of gags primarily aimed at ribbing
1991's Kevin Costner blockbuster. Even Hummie Mann’s score is breezy
enough (the love theme being surprisingly sweet), though I still wonder
even now why Brooks’ relationship with John Morris terminated as
abruptly as it did.
Fox’s Blu-Ray transfer
of “Robin Hood: Men In Tights” is pretty much
the strongest of the group of BD’s debuting here, with DTS Master Audio
sound complimenting the fun. Extras, though, are sparse (just the
trailer and a vintage HBO featurette), but admirers of Mann’s score
will be happy to hear it presented here, fully isolated in DTS Master
Audio sound.
The entire package is
presented in an elongated hardbound case (similar
in design to the “Planet of the Apes” Blu-Ray anthology), with an
impressive hardcover book sporting full-color photos with some
background comments and quotes from Brooks. Thankfully, unlike that
“Apes” package (which uncomfortably forced each disc onto a
flimsily-glued hub on the packaging), the movies are contained in
cardboard pouches in a separate foldout, though there’s no information
on each disc’s specific special features (for that, you’ll need to
refer to this handy review again!).
Overall it’s a perfect
gift for all Brooks fans, just in time for the
holidays.
New Blu-Ray Releases THE HANGOVER
Blu-Ray and DVD (***, 100/108 mins., 2009, R/Unrated; Warner). WHAT
IT IS: One of the year’s box-office smashes, director Todd Phillips
struck comedy gold with this irresistibly funny, often uproarious
account of four pals (Bradley Cooper, Ed Helms, Zach Galifianakis and
Justin Bartha) who head to Vegas for a weekend of fun prior to Bartha’s
upcoming wedding. Unfortunately, Cooper, Helms and Galifianakis wake up
after a wild night out without any knowledge of what just transpired,
the only evidence being a small baby and a giant tiger that have taken
up residence in their hotel room! Fast-paced and filled with memorable
situations and quotable lines (Galifianakis is particularly
hysterical), “The Hangover” is undoubtedly one of the funniest comedies
Hollywood has turned out in years, and despite its R rating for some
infrequent gross-out gags, many of the movie’s most amusing bits come
out of honest, pure comedic situations that’d be hilarious even without
the picture’s raunchy trimmings. TECH SPECS: Warner’s Blu-Ray edition
of “The Hangover” includes both the R-rated theatrical version of the
film as well as an extended Unrated cut with eight extra minutes of
footage. There are also numerous featurettes, a picture-in-picture
commentary with Cooper, Galifianakis, Helms and Phillips, a gag reel,
Ken Jeong’s improv and more. There’s also a digital copy for portable
media players on-hand. The standard DVD edition, meanwhile, includes
the digital copy but not the picture-in-picture commentary. Visually
the BD disc includes a fine VC-1 encoded transfer with Dolby TrueHD
audio, while the DVD boasts a 16:9 (2.35) transfer with 5.1 Dolby
Digital sound. AISLE SEAT MERRY BOTTOM LINE: Any movie that can make
Mike Tyson funny has to be something special, and “The Hangover” is
indeed a bona-fide comedic gem. Sure to be a viewer favorite for years
to come Phillips’ film, scripted by Jon Lucas and Scott Moore, delivers
the laughs consistently for its 100 minutes, making it one of the
year’s most pleasant surprises.
HARRY POTTER AND THE
HALF-BLOOD PRINCE Blu-Ray and DVD (**½, 153 mins., 2009, PG;
Warner). WHAT IT IS: The sixth book in J.K. Rowling’s series
makes for the least satisfying of the Harry Potter film franchise,
serving mainly to set up its concluding installment without telling a
particularly compelling story of its own. This time out Harry learns
more about the evil sorcerer Voldemort, whose villainy continues to
grow and whose back story Dumbeldore (Michael Gambon) wants Harry to
understand, in order to better prepare him for the challenges that
follow. Flashbacks, a few potions, and romantic relationships between
Hermoine (Emma Watson) and Ron (Rupert Grint), as well as Harry and
Ron’s sister, comprise much of the action of “The Half-Blood Prince,”
which has some nice moments and an exciting finish, but really takes
its time getting there with aspects that are likely to please Harry’s
legions of fans but come off as extraneous when taken on their own
terms. It also appears that the series is utilizing more and more
green-screen, as the cinematography here appears flat and “digital” in
nature, particularly in comparison with prior entries in the series.
TECH SPECS: Warner’s three-disc Blu-Ray edition of “The Half Blood
Prince” boasts a fine VC-1 encoded 1080p transfer with Dolby TrueHD
audio. As I just mentioned, there’s very much a CGI-like appearance to
the visuals here, with even some of the sequences in Hogwarts looking
less like location shooting than green-screen renders. Nicholas
Hooper’s score, while again lacking the thematic richness that John
Williams brought to the series’ first three installments, is at least
an improvement on his “Order of the Phoenix” offering, though the
TrueHD soundtrack is heavily accented towards the effects and score,
with dialogue mixed too low in comparison. Extras include additional
scenes, a “Maximum Movie Mode” interactive function with
picture-in-picture goodies, loads of behind-the-scenes featurettes and
a digital copy for portable media players. The DVD edition configures
these extras somewhat differently, while also offering a digital copy
and a perfectly acceptable 16:9 (2.35) transfer with 5.1 Dolby Digital
sound. AISLE SEAT MERRY BOTTOM LINE: Potter fanatics ate up “The
Half-Blood Prince” at the box-office, the movie surpassing $300 million
domestically and double that mark worldwide. Still, no matter how
magical the financial receipts, I couldn’t help but think this one felt
like a warm-up for the forthcoming “Deathly Hallows,” the first portion
of which hits theaters next November.
EXTRACT Blu-Ray
(**½, 92 mins., 2009, R; Miramax/Buena Vista). WHAT IT
IS: Mike Judge’s latest comedy failed to find an audience in theaters
last summer -- a trait it shares with Judge’s prior cinematic output,
particularly the cult favorite “Office Space.” “Extract,” his latest
film, stars Jason Bateman as the owner of Reynold’s Extract, who’s
considering selling the company to General Mills and is bored with his
marriage to wife Kristen Wiig. After a night of drug-induced mania,
Bateman takes the advice of his bartender pal (Ben Affleck) and opts to
have an affair with a new employee (Mila Kunis) who’s really a con
artist, leading to all kinds of shenanigans. “Extract” is an odd but
modestly entertaining character study that’s a lot less quirky than the
subject matter suggests, offering a fair amount of chuckles but nothing
in the way of outright hilarity. Part of that is due to Judge wanting
the audience to take these characters more seriously than in his prior
work, with the writer-director infusing more heart into the drama than
you might anticipate. It doesn’t quite come off -- the slender story
wraps up before the 90-minute mark and isn’t developed enough to engage
you the way Judge intends -- but it’s still an amusing little film
that’s worth seeing, especially for its lead performances from Bateman,
Affleck, Wiig, and a somewhat under-utilized J.K. Simmons. TECH SPECS:
Miramax’s Blu-Ray edition of “Extract” offers a fine AVC encoded 1080p
transfer with DTS Master Audio sound and extras including one brief
deleted scene, a few minutes of extended scenes, and a featurette on
the film’s production. AISLE SEAT BOTTOM LINE: “Extract” is one of
those flawed but watchable films that feels right at home on video,
where its shortcomings can be more easily overlooked than if you had
paid $12 to see it in a theater. Recommended with some reservations.
THE GREEN MILE
Blu-Ray (**½, 188 mins., 1999, R; Warner). WHAT IT IS:
Writer-director Frank Darabont’s 1999 follow-up to “The Shawshank
Redemption” was yet another Stephen King prison story adapted to the
screen -- though what was a far more layered and developed
literary source than "Shawshank" turns into far less of an involving
cinematic experience by comparison. This death row tale
with supernatural elements, chronicling the gentle giant John Coffey's
tenure on death row in Louisiana during the Great Depression, is
depressingly bland and dramatically static, plodding through its
bloated running time with an air of self-importance while disregarding
the pulpy, serialized nature of King's source material. Part of the
problem is that Darabont's obvious faithfulness to the novel's plot is
contrasted with his rather bland filmmaking approach. There's no
substance to the drama, none of King's biting commentary. While
Darabont captures the "Point A to Point B" narrative events, he misses
the grit and heart that King's book provided in spades. What results is
a film that moves so slowly and on such an even dramatic keel that it
never conveys the life and energy that the story held on the page, in
effect turning a low-key emotional tale into a bloated "Hollywood
movie" that doesn't appear to be worth all the fuss after three-plus
hours of celluloid. Tom Hanks (as prison guard Paul Edgecombe), Michael
Clarke Duncan (as John Coffey), and David Morse (as another guard on
the "Mile") are all terrific, but “The Green Mile” is so downright
maudlin at times -- as opposed to the novel's more balanced,
bittersweet examination of life and death -- that it never captures the
atmosphere and various layers that made King's serial so moving and
captivating. TECH SPECS: Warner’s “Digibook” Blu-Ray edition of “The
Green Mile” includes a lovely VC-1 encoded transfer with Dolby TrueHD
audio. Extras include Darabont’s commentary from the original DVD as
well as extra scenes, trailers, make-up and screen tests, a documentary
and featurette. AISLE SEAT MERRY BOTTOM LINE: It’s obvious that Frank
Darabont loved the source material here, but his overly noble
filmmaking approach (obviously thinking “Oscar”) turned an emotional
tale into a bloated "Hollywood movie" that overstays its welcome. While
the movie may be worth a look for patient viewers, despite its
high-profile cast and filmmakers, I'm not too certain that “The Green
Mile” wouldn't have been better off being adapted as a
made-for-television project, where the multi-night form and lower
budget might have been more ideally suited for one of King's finest
works.
SECONDHAND LIONS
Blu-Ray (***, 109 mins., 2003, PG; New Line). WHAT IT IS:
Warm-hearted, appealing family film about a precocious 14-year-old
(Haley Joel Osment) who learns a great deal about life and adulthood
from the fantastic tales spun by his two uncles (Michael Caine, Robert
Duvall). Similar in tone to Tim Burton’s “Big Fish” but more satisfying
on the whole, this underrated Tim McCanlies film offers positive
messages and insight, along with terrific performances from all three
leads. TECH SPECS: New Line’s Blu-Ray edition of “Secondhand Lions”
includes commentary from McCanlies, additional/alternate scenes,
featurettes, a visual effects comparison piece, the trailer and TV
spots. Both the AVC encoded transfer and Dolby TrueHD soundtrack are
each terrific. AISLE SEAT MERRY BOTTOM LINE: Ideal for younger viewers
and parents alike, “Secondhand Lions” did moderately well at the
box-office and deserves another look from viewers. Warner’s new Blu-Ray
gives them that opportunity via a top-notch transfer and soundtrack.
Recommended! G-FORCE Blu-Ray
(**½, 88 mins., 2009, PG; Disney). WHAT IT IS:
Genetically enhanced and government-trained guinea pigs do their part
to save the world in this fast-paced box-office hit for kids from
producer Jerry Bruckheimer. Hoyt Yeatman’s movie offers as much
shenanigans as you would anticipate from a live-action adventure with
CGI’d hamsters, particularly with Nicolas Cage, Sam Rockwell, Penelope
Cruz, Jon Favreau and Tracy Morgan voicing the movie’s tiny heroes.
It’s
all silly but stylishly executed for what it is, with Zach
Galifianakis, Will Arnett and Bill Nighy providing some amusement on
the human level. TECH SPECS: Disney’s three-disc BD set includes a
colorful, razor-sharp AVC encoded 1080p transfer with DTS HD audio
(sporting a predictably “Bruckheimer-esque” score by Trevor Rabin) and
extras including deleted scenes, a music video, bloopers, and light
Making Of featurettes aimed with youngsters in mind. The standard DVD
is also on-hand, along with a digital copy for portable media players.
AISLE SEAT MERRY BOTTOM LINE: “G-Force” is no kind of classic, but it’s
not any worse than the premise sounds, making it a safe choice for
kid-viewing this holiday season.
THE WIZARDS OF
WAVERLY PLACE: THE MOVIE Extended Edition DVD (98 mins., 2009; Disney).
WHAT IT IS: Fetaure-length continuation of the popular Disney
Channel series reunites its original cast (Selena Gomez, David Henrie,
Jake T. Austin among others) as the Russo family goes on vacation to
retrieve a “Stone of Dreams.” Colorful action and life lessons abound
in this amiable production that ought to please its intended audience.
TECH SPECS: Disney’s DVD includes a 16:9 (1.78) transfer with 5.1 Dolby
Digital sound and extras including several Making Of featurettes aimed
at the feature’s young audience. There’s also a “color-changing wishing
stone with clip” bundled in the package. AISLE SEAT MERRY BOTTOM LINE:
Tween-age viewers should have fun with this extended edition of “The
Wizards of Waverly Place” movie.
TV on DVD:
Documentaries, Reality & More
THE SECRET LIFE
OF THE AMERICAN TEENAGER Volume 3 DVD (522 mins., 2009; Buena Vista). WHAT
IT IS: Brenda Hampton’s popular ABC Family series gets even nuttier in
this third volume of episodes, representing the latter portion of its
2009 broadcast output.
Included among the mind-bending story lines are Jack and Grace’s
decision to go all the way, which is accompanied by the death of
Grace’s father (John Schneider, who had the good sense to exit the
show) in an airplane accident. Meanwhile, Amy (Shailene Woodley) tries
to mix high school with raising her son, leading to more complications
with boyfriend Ben (Kenny Baumann) and her child’s father, bad-boy
Ricky. Soap opera antics and unbelievable moralizing combine to make
this a guilty pleasure through and through, but reality exited this
series long, long ago. TECH SPECS: Buena Vista’s DVD edition of “Secret
Life”’s “third volume” offers 12 episodes in fine 16:9 (1.78) transfers
with 5.1 Dolby Digital soundtracks. Extras include the pilot episode of
another successful ABC Family show, “Make it Or Break It,” plus a
Q&A with the cast. AISLE SEAT MERRY BOTTOM LINE: Though “Secret
Life” means well, and attempts to discuss adult subjects in a way that
its target teenage audience can relate to, it’s helplessly ridiculous
and unbelievable at every stage. I can’t say it’s not entertaining
though, even if it’s for all the wrong reasons.
KYLE XY: Season
3 DVD (436 mins., 2009; Buena Vista). WHAT IT IS: Third and
final season of the ABC Family series finds the mysterious Kyle (Matt
Dallas) uncovering his secret past and working with the Trager family
who adopted him to thwart a group of baddies who want to clone Kyle for
their own nefarious purposes. Most storylines were resolved in this
last group of episodes from “Kyle XY,” though some fans did lament a
few loose, dangling narrative ends that were left hanging. TECH SPECS:
Buena Vista’s three-disc set sports the complete third season of the
series in 16:9 (1.78) transfers and 5.1 Dolby Digital soundtracks.
Extras include deleted scenes, a never-before-seen series conclusion,
commentaries and a fan’s guide to the show’s finish. AISLE SEAT MERRY
BOTTOM LINE: Young aficionados of the series ought to be satisfied with
this final batch of shows from “Kyle XY,” presented in a satisfying
box-set from Buena Vista.
ER: Season 12
DVD (975 mins., 2005-06; Warner). WHAT IT IS: NBC’s
long-running series ended last spring, but fans can relive some of the
show’s more turbulent, later seasons with Warner’s box-set of the
series’ 12th year. Included among the story lines this time out are
Kristen Johnson’s arrival as new nurse manager Eve Spellman; John
Stamos’ debut as paramedic Tony Gates; and a number of “special” event
episodes ranging from Carter’s work in Darfur to a Chicago flood. TECH
SPECS: Warner’s box-set of “ER”s 12th season includes fresh 16:9 (1.85)
transfers with 2.0 Dolby Stereo soundtracks. Extras include a number of
deleted scenes. AISLE SEAT MERRY BOTTOM LINE: Though its ratings
declined as the years went on, “ER” still boasted a number of fans who
stuck with the series through thick and thin. If you know one of them,
Warner’s Season 12 DVD will make a fine belated Christmas present when
it’s released on January 12th.
ICE ROAD
TRUCKERS: Season 3 DVD (aprx. 11 hours, 2009; History/Newvideo). WHAT
IT IS: Season three of the popular History Channel series follows life
on the bumpy, freezing Prudhoe Bay (250 miles north of the Arctic
Circle), where truckers do a mad dash during a three-month period to
move critical supplies over the ice. Exciting, real-life
situations prevail through the series’ third season, which once again
follows veteran drivers Hugh Rowland and Alex Debogorski among a new
slate of truckers. TECH SPECS: History/Newvideo’s four-disc DVD box set
offers the complete third season of “Ice Road Truckers” in fine
widescreen transfers and stereo soundtracks. Some additional footage is
also on-tap. AISLE SEAT MERRY BOTTOM LINE: One of the higher rated and
more satisfying reality series on TV today, “Ice Road Truckers” is
exciting and compelling entertainment for what it is. Recommended.
CRISS ANGEL
MINDFREAK: Megaset DVD (aprx. 36 hours, 2009 compilation;
A&E/Newvideo). WHAT IT IS: A&E’s hit series with master
of illusion Criss Angel is back on DVD in a lavishly produced, 15-disc
box-set offering collectible pop up packaging. Included among the
episodes here are six new-to-DVD shows, plus episode commentaries,
interviews, guides to creating your own illusions, additional scenes,
two Best Of shows, a text biography, photo gallery and more. Highly
recommended for all Criss Angel enthusiasts.
THE SHERLOCK
HOLMES COLLECTION DVD (aprx. 5 hours, 1968; A&E/Newvideo): After
having essayed Sherlock Holmes in Hammer’s fine rendition of “The Hound
of the Baskervilles,” Peter Cushing returned to portray Sir Arthur
Conan Doyle’s great detective in a ‘60s BBC series that was reportedly
plagued with production delays and budgetary overruns. Even worse, the
ravages of time have claimed all but five episodes of the ‘60s Holmes,
which A&E has brought to Region 1 in a three-disc set sporting “The
Sign of Four,” “The Blue Carbuncle,” “A Study in Scarlet,” “The
Boscombe Valley Mystery,” and another adaptation of “The Hound of the
Baskervilles.” The full-screen transfers are presented from their
healthiest surviving elements with clear stereo soundtracks and a bonus
documentary, “Sherlock Holmes: The Great Detective.”
THE UNKNOWN
CIVIL WAR SERIES: Gettysburg (676 mins.) and Greatest Battles of the
Civil War DVD (415 mins., MPI): MPI’s two new volumes of civil
war documentaries ought to be a hit with history enthusiasts.
“Gettysburg” provides 13 programs focusing on the bloodiest battle
fought on American soil with rare photos, reenactments and interviews,
while “Greatest Battles” likewise sports eight documentaries on the
skirmishes of Antietam, Appomattox, Chancellorsville, Chickamauga,
Shiloh, Vicksburg, Petersburg and Gettysburg as well. Full-screen
transfers and stereo soundtracks adorn each of the double-disc sets.
HERE’S LUCY
Season 2 DVD (12 hours., 1969-70; MPI): Sophomore season of
Lucille
Ball’s second long-running network comedy includes 24 fully remastered
episodes with guest stars including Vivian Vance, Johnny Carson, Carol
Burnett, Milton Berle, Ann-Margret, Liberace, Wayne Newton, Lawrence
Welk and Wally Cox among others. As with MPI’s season one edition of
“Here’s Lucy” there are some splendid special features on-hand,
including new video intros from Lucie Arnaz and Desi Arnaz, Jr., a
“lost” interview with Carol Burnett, home movies, original network and
syndication promos, and more. A must for Lucy fans.
THE FUGITIVE
Season 3, Volume 2 DVD (1966, aprx. 13 hours; CBS): CBS’ latest
compilation of episodes from the classic David Janssen series sports
the back-half of its third-season episodes (15 to be exact). Remastered
full-screen transfers and mono soundtracks comprise the goods in this
four-disc set, which again, does not seem to suffer from the
substantial music edits some of its earlier DVD releases did (though
there’s still a packaging disclaimer about music being changed for home
video).
PERRY MASON
Season 4, Volume 2 DVD (1961, aprx. 10 hours; CBS): Raymund
Burr is back as Perry Mason in this three-disc CBS set compiling its
final 12 episodes from its fourth (1960-61) season, co-starring Barbara
Hale as Della Street and William Hopper as the irrepressible Paul
Drake. Fine black-and-white transfers and mono soundtracks make this
another recommended purchase for aficionados of Earle Stanley Gardner’s
crusading counselor.
Quick Takes
DEADLINE
Blu-Ray (*½, 89 mins., 2009, R; First Look): Brittany
Murphy and Thora Birch have sadly fallen to the level of
direct-to-video fodder with this disappointing supernatural (or is it?)
thriller. Murphy plays an aspiring screenwriter (ha!) who heads to a
secluded (of course) Victorian home where she witnesses apparitions of
a couple (Thora Birch and Marc Blucas) who had lived there before, and
whose videotapes remain in the attic. The resolution really sinks this
otherwise marginal thriller from director Sean McConville. First Look’s
Blu-Ray edition includes behind-the-scenes footage, a 1080p transfer
and both DTS and 5.1 Dolby Digital sound.
TOOLBOX MURDERS
Blu-Ray (94 mins., 1978, Unrated; Blue Underground): Before
“Halloween” and “Friday the 13th” launched the slasher genre, Dennis
Donnelly directed this occasionally gross but more often than not
tedious affair with a crazy handyman using his bag of tools to take out
“immoral” women on the streets of L.A. Former child actress (and later
animal rights activist) Pamelyn Ferdin stars alongside “Land of the
Lost” veteran Wesley Eure in this 1978 release, which was infamous at
the time for its violence but comes across today as a product of its
era. Blue Underground’s Blu-Ray edition of “The Toolbox Murders” does
look quite nice given its age and independent origins, the BD offering
a 1080p transfer on a single-layer BD25 disc with DTS Master Audio
sound on-hand. Extras include commentary with producer Tony DiDio,
cinematographer Gary Graver and Ferdin, plus the trailer, TV and radio
spots, and an intevriew with co-star Marianne Walter.
WORLD’S
GREATEST DAD Blu-Ray (**, 99 mins., 2009, R; Magnolia): Richard
Kelly of “Donnie Darko” fame co-produced this strange semi-comedy from
writer-director Bobcat Goldthwait. Robert Williams here essays a poetry
teacher far removed from “Dead Poets Society,” with an obnoxious son
(Daryl Sabara) who doesn’t appreciate him and a girlfriend (Alexie
Gilmore) almost ashamed of their relationship. Something tragic
ultimately happens (which I won’t spoil here) which gives Williams’
character all the possible fame and fortune he wants, but at what
price? A few intermittent laughs pop up here and there but “World’s
Greatest Dad” is a really offbeat, at times uncomfortable to watch
effort from Goldthwait, who found more success behind the lens with the
underrated “Shakes the Clown” from years back. Magnolia’s Blu-Ray
edition of the picture boasts a pungent 1080p transfer with DTS Master
Audio sound and extras including Goldthwait’s commentary, outtakes,
deleted scenes and making of featurettes.
INTO THE STORM
DVD (98 mins., 2009; HBO): A superb performance from Brendan
Gleeson as Winston Churchill anchors this second effort from writer
Hugh Whitemore and director Thaddeus O’Sullivan, following their prior
“The Gathering Storm” telefilm. That earlier program followed Churchill
to the outbreak of WWII, and “Into the Storm” does what the title
implies, portraying Winston as a great wartime leader as well as his
struggles
with wife Clementine. HBO’s DVD edition boasts a 16:9 (1.85) transfer
with 5.1 Dolby Digital sound and extras including commentary from
Whitemore and producer Frank Doelger and a Making Of featurette.
NEW YORK YANKEES
WORLD SERIES 2009 COLLECTION DVD (aprx. 21 hours; A&E) NEW YORK YANKEES
2009: Season of Pride, Tradition and Glory (66 mins.; A&E): For
that Bronx Bomber fan on your shopping list this year, look no further
than these two new releases from A&E, celebrating (gulp – yes I am
a Red Sox fan) the New York Yankees’ latest world championship.
The eight-disc,
terrifically produced Yankee World Series box-set
presents a definitive chronicle of the Yanks’ run to World Series,
offering the complete battle with the Philadelphia Phillies and their
clinching ALCS Game 6 win over the Anaheim Angels. The best element of
this release is the ability to choose the audio feed for the games,
whether it’s Fox’s national broadcast tandem of Joe Buck and Tim
McCarver, or the Yankee radio duo of John Sterling and Suzyn Waldman
(there are also tracks with the Phillies announcers and the ESPN
Deportes Spanish language crew as well!). This gives the set a truly
comprehensive feel, with other extras including 2009 regular season
highlights, other post-season game segments, player interviews, and of
course the trophy celebrations.
If the set is a little
steep in price, there’s also the single-disc,
YES Network-produced documentary “Season of Pride, Tradition and
Glory,” a hour-long plus effort narrated by John Sterling (or in
Spanish with Alvaro Martin) with all the requisite highlights and
player interviews you can think of. Very well-produced, it’s a fine
digest of another world championship season for the Yanks.
FALLING UP DVD
(98 mina., 2008, Not Rated; Anchor Bay): Comedy with Joseph
Cross as a Manhattan doorman who falls for the gorgeous daughter (Sarah
Roemer) of his building’s wealthiest tenant. A good cast (Rachael Leigh
Cook, Annette O’Toole, Joe Pantoliano) stars in this breezy,
sitcom-like film from director David M. Rosenthal, which Anchor Bay
brings to DVD on January 5th with a fine 16:9 (1.78) widescreen
transfer, 2.0 stereo sound and a behind-the-scenes featurette.
NEXT
TIME: 500 DAYS OF SUMMER and more of the first discs of 2010! Until
then, don't
forget
to drop in
on the official Aisle Seat Message
Boards and
direct
any emails to our email
address. Cheers, a Merry Christmas and
Happy New Year to one and all!
Copyright 1997-2009 All Reviews, Site and Design by Andre
Dursin